Mint Chocolate Chip Cake
My husband’s birthday is this week, and mint chocolate chip ice cream is one of his favorites. Plus St. Patrick’s Day is approaching, so I thought a Mint Chocolate Chip Cake would be perfect for either.

When I first met my husband, his favorite ice cream was regular chocolate chip, which I thought was kind of booooring. I was always a mint chocolate chip girl, and one day he tried mine and realized he’d been an ice cream loser for all of his born days, and immediately converted.

Which just goes to show that he was lost without me and it’s probably a good thing for him that we got married. He would have spent his entire life eating the wrong ice cream, and he wouldn’t get picked on on a blog that tens of people read, and plus, I’m fairly convinced that any other wife would just buy him a cake at the stupid supermarket.

Supermarket cakes don’t have magic in them. Just lots of shortening. Fact.
I’m not normally a homemade cake person. I’ve tried both homemade and mixes, and find a lot of homemade recipes to be dry, and fairly expensive to make. I’ve heard good things about the Hershey Perfectly Chocolate Cake though, and the recipe is simple enough, so I decided to give it a whirl with just a few minor changes.
It’s amazing. So rich and chocolatey and not dry in the slightest. It’s a gorgeous almost black color, which contrasts perfectly with the mint chocolate chip buttercream. It’s one of my favorite cakes I’ve ever made, and I hope you try it and love it too!!
Happy Birthday, sweet husband!! You are always a good sport, you know how to fix things, you’re an excellent spider killer, you make adorable babies, and you never question my excessive make up and shoe collections. In other words — you’re the perfect man for me.Mint Chocolate Chip Cake
**cake portion adapted from Hershey
INGREDIENTS
- Cake:
- 2 cups white sugar
- 1 3/4 cup all purpose flour
- 1 cup unsweetened, Dutch process cocoa powder (I used Hershey Special Dark)
- 1 1/2 tsp baking powder
- 1 1/2 tsp baking soda
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 2 eggs
- 1 cup milk
- 1/2 cup vegetable oil
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 3/4 cup boiling water
- Frosting:
- 2 sticks (1 cup) salted butter, slightly softened
- 1/3 cup heavy cream
- 2 tsp mint extract
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- Drop or two of green food coloring
- 4 cups powdered sugar
- 2 oz semisweet chocolate, finely chopped
INSTRUCTIONS
1. Preheat oven to 350. Grease and flour 2 eight or nine inch pans.
2. In the bowl of a mixer, combine sugar, flour, cocoa powder, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Whisk together until fully combined. Add eggs, milk, oil, and vanilla and beat on medium speed for 2 minutes. Scrape the sides of the bowl, then slowly stir in the boiling water. Pour batter evenly into prepared pans and bake for 30 -40 minutes, until tops of cakes spring back when you lightly touch in the center.
3. Remove cakes from oven. Allow to cool in pans for about 10 minutes, then remove to finish cooling on wire racks.
4. Prepare frosting: In the bowl of a mixer, beat butter, cream, and both extracts on medium speed until smooth. With mixer speed on low, slowly add powdered sugar and mix until just combined. Add food coloring and increase speed to medium high and beat for about minute, until frosting is light, smooth, and fluffy. If frosting is too thick, add another Tablespoon or two of cream and beat for 30 more seconds. Add chopped chocolate and mix on low until incorporated. Frost cooled cake.
Notes:
Refrigerate cake until serving.
Do not sub chocolate chips for chopped chocolate in frosting — it will make the cake very difficult to frost. I used bakers chocolate, but feel free to use your favorite dark chocolate bar.
To make frosting the cake easier, wrap the cakes in plastic wrap and or refrigerate for an hour or two before frosting. It will make the cakes more firm, which is easier for handling. Bonus — it also makes your cakes more moist.
Have a happy Monday, everyone!!









Thanks for visiting my blog! I realize you could be doing more important things with your time. Like watching the news or washing socks. I hope you stay awhile. Much more fun than socks, I promise. 





Happy Birthday to your mans! And you are totally right, NO MAGIC in supermarket cakes AND the Hershey Chocolate cake is the BEST-est.
This is a gorgeous cake Kristan! Your husband is very lucky and it sounds like you are too :)
What a lovely cake!
Looks delicious and magical!
A thing of beauty!
I need a slice! Beautiful cake!
Looks like a giant scoop of mint chocolate chip! YUM!
Oh my word! This looks like heaven!
Happy Birthday Mr. Roland!!!! Kristan is one lucky, blessed and happy woman to have you as her husband. The two of you do make perfect children together. Kristan — that looks exactly what I’d want for my birthday cake. p.s. My birthday is Sept. 23 — plenty of time for you to figure out how to mail it 3,000 miles!
Yum! Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream is my absolute favorite! Even my three year old knows this — and always pretends thats what she’s scooping up at her play kitchen! My question about the Hershey cake — it is quite dense? That’s what I’ve always noticed about making cakes from scratch. They tend to be a lot heavier … not as light and springy and airy as the box mixes tend to be. I’d love to give it a try for my husband’s birthday next month if this is the case! : ]
I would say it’s a little dense, but not as heavy as most homemade cakes. I really liked it a lot!! I’ll definitely be making it again. :)
This just looks amazing! I love mint chocolate chip ice cream, so I can’t wait to try this!
Thank you, thank you, your cake is absolutely gorgeous, you have given me a great idea for my hubbies birthday, I can’t wait to try it out, he is a super fan of mint choc chip and chocolate cake, so the two together will just be awesome.
This looks soooo good!
Mint chocolate chip is the only way – chocolate chip is absolutely boring and should never be made :) So glad you set your husband straight. I totally want a slice!
It is so beautiful, I can taste it. I need a piece right now at 6:00am.
It’s my birthday this week too and I love Mint chocolate chip, maybe I’ll make this for my birthday!!
I love how this frosting looks JUST like mint chocolate chip ice cream with the shaved chocolate. So much better than even tiny chocolate chips. I think I might have my cake baking daughter make this tonight :)
Happy birthday to your hubby!
Turkey Hill makes the best Choco-Mint Chip ice cream… I can easily eat far too much of it when it’s just the perfect stage of ‘melty’.
This cake looks fantastic, and the pictures had my 8 year old jumping up and down as he asked me to make it!
OMG I love this cake!! I live in England (American Ex-Pat) and they do not have mint chocolate chip ice cream in the stores. I mean they might in London, but I don’t live in London somewhere, but I haven’t found it locally. Sometimes if I’m lucky Thorton’s (a chocolate store) will have it, but it’s white and just isn’t the same!!
I’m not sure why I felt the need to share all that!! I just wanted to say how amazing this cake looks and I think I should make it to get my mint chocolate fix!
Hope your husband enjoyed the cake and had a lovely day!!
What a lovely cake! I was just wondering why it needs to be refrigerated?
After the cake cools completely I refrigerate it or even freeze it for a few days (or longer). After being in the fridge it’s firmer and easier to frost. If I freeze it — again I let the cake cool completely, triple wrap it in Saran wrap then put it in a plastic bag. When I want to frost it I take the cake out of the freezer and let it defrost completely while still wrapped in the plastic. Again, having been frozen it’s firmer and easier to frost. That’s my experience. You don’t “need” to put it in the refrigerator — but you MUST be sure the cake layers have cooled completely or the icing will just slide off. Good luck!
Thanks for the quick response! I should have been more clear in my initial question, I actually wanted to know why it’s got the “Refrigerate cake until serving.” part. Is this just a taste preference for an ice cream flavored cake or is it a stability issue?
Thanks!
I like to keep it refrigerated because of all the dairy that goes into the frosting.
This is such a fun idea! Love this cake :)
The cake is gorgeous! Mint chocolate chip is my husbands favorite too, so I know he would love this. Too bad his birthday past already :( Oh well, guess I will have to find another reason to make it.
Happy Birthday to your husband!
This cake is so great! Love the color and flavor.
Gorgeous cake, I’ll have to try this recipe, thanks for sharing! Mint and chocolate were def meant to go together!
This is such a beautiful cake!! The frosting seriously looks like mint chocolate chip ice cream :)
Good thing this is not in front of me because it would be trouble!!
I love that it looks like you just slathered your cake in ice cream. That frosting is the perrrrrfect shade of mint green.
I have been a Hershey’s Chocolate cake fan since I was in high school… many, many years ago! And I love mint and chocolate together, so this cake has to be a winner! :)
Nothing wrong with cake mixes – they just measured the dry ingredients for you. You can always tweak them like adding a little coffee and some extra cocoa powder to chocolate, substituting buttermilk, sour cream or mayo for some of the liquid.
Loved your recent video with your fellow rice krispies blogger!
I’m in LOVE with this cake…LOVE-love-LOVE…it looks like mint ice cream, yummy!!!
That is also one of my favorite chocolate cake recipes – it happens to make perfectly domed cupcakes!
Love this and your husband is a very lucky man:-)
Gorgeous cake! The frosting looks exactly like mint chocolate chip ice cream, which also happens to be one of my favorite flavors of ice cream. Yum!
Happy Birthday to your husband! That cakes does look amazing and he is so lucky to have you in his life :)
Aww, your poor ice cream loser husband. Eating the wrong kind of ice cream for so long! It’s a good thing he has you to straighten him out :) A plain vanilla and chocolate chip cake just wouldn’t have been so pretty.
Your husband is a lucky man! This cake looks so pretty and I love mint chip ice cream!!
What? Mint chocolate chip ice cream is like my favorite ice cream flavor, everrr. Now, this cake has me drooling!
My first vist to your blog – love it! This cake looks amazing – love mint chocolate chip. As I read through older posts I found a link to stacker mallows – I have seen those on other sites and no one would ever tell me where to get such a thing – so thank you!!!
[...] http://www.confessionsofacookbookqueen.com/2013/03/mint-chocolate-chip-cake [...]
This cake is by far the prettiest thing I’ve seen all day! Also… I think I might eat the whole thing in one sitting if I had my way.
Hi! Your post is so funny and sweet! Happy birthday to your husband! I’m sure he’s very blessed to have you as his wife – so thoughtful, creative…and bakes awesome goodies!!!
will try to make this recipe soon :D
[...] divine looking Mint Chocolate Chip Cake from the ever entertaining Kristan at Confessions of a Cookbook [...]
Happy birthday to your husband! You made a gorgeous looking cake that I’m sure he loved.
P.S. Any man that’s keeps *mum* about his wife’s shoe and make-up collection is a keeper. You are both so lucky to have found each other but you already knew that.
just wandering if it would be possible to use wiltons gel coloring?
Yes, that is great!! It’s usually what I use too :)
[...] I hope a leprechaun brings us this Mint Chocolate Chip Cake to celebrate St. Patrick’s [...]
Who do I talk to about getting one of these for MY birthday?!
Oh, Kristan! I am so totally and completely in LOVE with this cake!!! I think I might have swooned when I saw that first picture. I’ve always been a mint chocolate chip ice cream girl, too! Totally making this for our next special occasion. Is Friday a special occasion?
PS…happy bday to your honey!
I just made this cake and it is currently in the oven. The batter was very thin, is this correct or did I do something wrong? Thank you
Yes, that is perfectly normal and it’s great!!
[...] This icing made the perfect biscuit filling, but could also be used on the outside of a cake like “Confessions of a Cookbook Queen” did http://www.confessionsofacookbookqueen.com/2013/03/mint-chocolate-chip-cake/ [...]
[...] Find the recipe and printable version here.. [...]
[...] them with this fabulous American-style buttercream I found on Confessions of a Cookbook Queen: Mint Chocolate Chip Frosting. It really does taste just like the ice [...]
Do you know if there are any adjustments for high altitude over 6000 ft (cake recipe)? We live at high altitude and cakes will sometimes fall in the center if adjustments are not made.