Sugar Cream Pie
When I first started my career as a mom and housewife, I was super defensive about how I spent my time.
But over the years, I’ve learned not to waste my time on people who have snotty things to say. I mean, the best revenge is REALLY letting them think I spend my day eating candy and watching TV while they work at a job they despise, so why not go along with it? I know what I do all day, that’s all I really need.
But when it comes to my husband, I feel defensive about my importantness.
Because he has a job where he talks to real people and they call him needing things and he has lunch at restaurant sometimes and honestly, I just don’t care for that. It feeds the ego, if you ask me.
So when he comes home and his phone is still ringing and he’s all, “wow, I had to be fifty places today”, I’m like “yes, well I’ve been doing homework with the human being that I grew from scratch, so have fun with those fifty people, whoever they are”.
It always works because growing a human trumps everything.
Unfortunately though, my husband knows how to do a lot of things, so sometimes making my day more important gets a little tricky. The other day he came home tired, telling me about the bathroom remodel he’d been doing and how he had to move plumbing in order to put a toilet in a different spot.
Luckily, I had to plunge the downstairs toilet earlier in the day after an “incident” with my child left it disgustingly clogged. So I was all, “yes, well while you were moving your clean toilet pipes, I was unclogging our toilet. Like…I was basically an actual plumber today. Sorry Mr. Fancy Remodeler, some of us actually have to get down to business in the trenches.”
I mean, I’d love to sympathize with him, but I just don’t have the time. Stuff here is just so darn rough what with plumbing and First Grade homework and making sure the DVR is set to record things properly.
Of course, I’m not a terrible wife or anything. Sometimes I sympathize and pat his arm and say things like “oh honey, that sounds like a looooong day” but then I get up to make him some coffee and make sure I’m limping on my way to the kitchen. Being on one’s feet all day just takes it’s toll on my orthopedic well being, you know?
It’s amazing I even have time to make desserts and things. Fortunately, this pie can be thrown together in a flash and tastes like it took all day. You know how some people are like, “I can’t make pie”? Well, they need to make THIS pie. It’s so easy, sets up nice and firm, and cuts like a dream.
This pie is really really good. Kind of like a custard pie, but a bit sweeter, with a creamier texture. I hope you love it too!!Sugar Cream Pie
From Allrecipes.com
INGREDIENTS
- 9 inch pie crust, baked and cooled
- 4 Tablespoons cornstarch
- 3/4 cup white sugar
- 4 Tablespoons butter, melted
- 2 1/4 cups half and half cream
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste
- For topping:
- 2 Tablespoons butter, melted
- 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
INSTRUCTIONS
1. In a medium sized heavy saucepan, whisk together cornstarch and sugar. Whisk in the 4 Tablespoons melted butter and half and half. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until mixture is the consistency of a thick pudding. Remove from heat and stir in vanilla.
2. Preheat oven broiler to high.
3. Pour mixture into pie crust and spread evenly. Drizzle with melted butter and sprinkle cinnamon over the top. Place under the broiler until butter begins to bubble all over the surface–keep a close eye because it doesn’t take long.
4. Let pie cool to room temperature, then chill several hours before serving.
Notes:
I used store bought crust, but if you have a favorite recipe you can use that instead.
I used vanilla bean paste in place of the extract and loved the tiny specks that were throughout the filling. Try it!!
Enjoy and have a happy Monday!!






Thanks for visiting my blog! I realize you could be doing more important things with your time. Like watching the news or washing socks. I hope you stay awhile. Much more fun than socks, I promise. 






WOW! That looks amazing! AND love the “growing the human” excuse! :-) Hilarious! ;-)
Haha, I’m gonna remember that: raising a human being trumps all. It’s so true; I am amazed how much work my mom does every single day.
Thanks for the recipe!
I am so using the line that I grew a human from scratch… awesome.
And I am not a pie maker, so if you say it can be done, well, then I believe you.
I just love the name of this: sugar cream pie! It sounds like a fairy tale.
Love it!
I’m defensive at work about how much time I spend working on my website, hah!
Sounds yummy and the recipe is definitely easy enough for me to try. I love that it looks like it would take a long time to make. ;-)
Mmmmmm… sugar donuts came to mind first. I’m digging the “bruleed” top on this. Can you pie me in the face with it?!
You crack me up! And the pie sounds heavenly!
This looks delicious – like creme brulee almost, cut without as much work!
You had me laughing out loud with the human-growing thing. I like it. I’m going to keep that one in my back pocket to use later. . . .
I laughed outloud reading this! Do you thinking could use flour instead of the corn starch? I am allergic to corn/corn products.
I would certainly give it a try, I’m not sure the cornstarch to flour ratio, but I bet it would turn out fine.
Someone once told me they read that the energy used during the human gestation period equals that of climbing a mountain the size of Mt. Everest. Whether it’s true or not, don’t think for a second that I didn’t play that card once during my pregnancy. Or twice. Or 736 times. Too bad I didn’t know about this pie during my pregnancy!
I SO agree on the using a “growing a human from scratch” line. I grew two at once… still use that one as often as I can.
This pie looks divine!
I too am a SAHM and I feel like I always have to justify what I do during the day to people. Especially the hubby for the same reasons. I love your take on it! It’s a great way to view it. =)
So thought. U were introducing. A new Baby on the way!! Lol and typing on my kindle sucks! !
This post seriously cracked me up! I’m going to have to remember that “human being that I grew from scratch” line for future use :) Your pie looks terrific!
this pie looks really good. i’ve been thinking of a pie to make and I just found it! :)
I suck at pie, but this looks so great, I might just try!
Sugar cream pie? I never knew such a pie existed..it’s like cheesecake, only better! WAY better!
Oh YUM!!! Sweeter than custard, sounds perfect, especially because I LOVE custard.
Hahaha! I can SO relate to this post! Also, sometimes when my husband comes home from the worst day ever, I still wish I could trade days with him, just to interact with an adult as a professional.
Um, this pie totally makes you a good wife!
Mmm, Sugar Cream Pie is a family favorite here! And I’ve been so surprised by people who’ve never even heard about it. I try to explain what it is, but I find it’s just better to eat it instead!
PS- As a “Domestic Engineer” as one man called me, I’m convinced the world would fall apart without us!
It would.
This looks amazingly delicious. And, cooking, cleaning, and taking care of our family is a hugely important job….especially when you have the added talents of making deliciousness like this pie.
The pie looks amazing! But, more importantly, I think anyone who stays home and chooses to raise their own child is the most amazing thing. I did it, (not counting a part-time weekend job for some of the time), for 16 years. Had to sacrifice A LOT, and skimp but I was determined to be the one to raise my child. I understand that there are others who have no choice for their own reasons.. but I will always believe a parent is best.
Now, my oldest son is about to start college with a 4.2 GPA (that was what HE did). He is my hero and I am so proud of him. So, as much as we struggled, I would do it all again!
SO, KUDOS TO YOU!!!
WOW–love the sounds and looks of this pie. I can’t wait to give it a try!
I want a slice!
That excuse definitely tops any other! This pie looks fantastic – I always have time for pie!
This pie looks ridiculous! Sugar? Cream? Hello. This is my life. :)
This…WILL BE made for Easter…
I seriously need this asap. Drooling at 6:50am, lol!
This is very similar to our South African “Milktart” – one of the oldest SA Traditionals. Can’t wait to try this version.
*Growing a human from scratch* is definitely a keeper comeback and we all know women are the only ones who can *get down in the trenches* with toilet incidents without donning HazMat suits :) Comes from all the diaper duty we performed with the little humans we grew from scratch!
This pie is magical!
Your stories entrance me. I have all the sympathy in the world for you, and I’m so glad you make things like this pie. Holy yum!
hahaha I love this post. Being a homemaker & mom is THE most important job out there!
O.
M.
G.
Hi,
Sounds scrummy – gotta make this one – not sure we get Half and Half in South Africa – can you give me a more detailed description?
Thanks,
Colette
It’s half heavy cream, half milk…so it’s thicker than milk but lighter than cream. Hope that helps!!
Two things: 1. I’m obsessed with cream. And 2. I’m obsessed with the texture of custard pies. I’m a housewife too and I grew two humans that left me with the back of a 90 year old woman so I deserve a pie! And this pie looks like my dream!
I love the name of this pie, it sounds fairy-tail-good.
You are hilarious! The pie sounds wonderful, and if I can trick people into thinking I worked all day, I am all for it!
On my list of things to do: grow a human being from scratch. Cause I need a trump card. So friggin’ hilarious. :)
Where do you buy the vanilla bean paste, do most supermarkets carry it? I found some at Amazon, but there are several different varieties, is there one particular kind you prefer? Thanks!!
[...] made Sugar Cream Pie. It’s what they feed unicorns and fairies, is what I’ve [...]
That’s my kind of pie – simple and delicious. I’ve bookmarked it and can’t wait to give it a try.
such a nice article…
I enjoyed reading your informative article and considering the points you made. You make a lot of sense. This is an excellent piece of writing. Thanks for sharing this so we can all read it….
[...] blogs that I read posted a recipe for the pie so I gave that one a try. You can find the recipe here. It was delicious! So why wasn’t it a success? It has vanilla in it. Hubby says [...]
[...] Sugar Cream Pie [...]
I was suggested this blog by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post
is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my difficulty.
You are amazing! Thanks!
raspberry ketone diet 1200 recently posted..raspberry ketone diet 1200
With havin so much content do you ever run
into any problems of plagorism or copyright violation?
My site has a lot of completely unique content I’ve either written myself or outsourced but it looks like a lot of it is popping it up all over the web without my agreement. Do you know any solutions to help prevent content from being ripped off? I’d really
appreciate it.
raspberry ketone diet plan recently posted..raspberry ketone diet plan