Dreamsicle Fudge
So, I’ve always had a secret dream of being Amish.
But I don’t want to be Amish for forever.
Just for a little while. You know, see what it’s like to live a simpler life and all that. No worrying about who is stalking my Facebook profile, or wondering if DJ Lance is really a good influence on my child (I question that man, I really do).
Plus, the Amish have really rosy cheeks. At least, they do on Lifetime movies, anyways. So that would totally make up for the lack of cosmetics.
And if you’re Amish, you don’t have to worry about things like car troubles….and paying a bunch of money to have your car towed. And waiting for days before anyone tells you what is wrong with it.
I’m on day 4 without my beloved Jeep, guys. My husband needs his truck for work, and I’ve been stuck at home for most of the week.
And I do mean stuck. There is literally nothing around for miles.
So I decided to make the most of the situation and fulfill my fantasy of being Amish.
But you know what I discovered? That when a person decides to dabble in Amish-ness, their friends just try and bring them down. I don’t know why…maybe they get green with envy. Maybe they are afraid of losing a dear friend to sheep shearing and butter churning. But whatever the reason, they are definitely not supportive.
According to my friends “K” and “LA”, being stuck in the country for days and days is not enough to qualify me as an Amish woman. It was also pointed out that Amish women do not have polka dotted fingernails.
I laugh, I really do. What do they know, sitting at their fancy jobs with their desks and their cars in the parking lot.
But to prove my point, I dug out my Amish cookbook. I thought I’d cook up a treat honoring my new heritage. And you’ll be happy to know that I found this recipe for a yummy orange and vanilla swirled fudge.
Oh, and guess what? The recipe calls for a jar of marshmallow creme.
Yep, it appears that marshmallow creme is an authentic Amish ingredient. Looks like the Amish are more modern than you guys think, hmmmm???
I just love being right.
**Recipe from Wanda E. Brunstetter’s Amish Friend’s Cookbook
INGREDIENTS
3/4 cup butter
3 cups sugar
3/4 cup whipping cream
12 oz pkg white chocolate chips or 12 (1 oz) squares white chocolate, chopped
1 (7 oz) jar marshmallow creme
3 teaspoons orange extract
12 drops yellow food coloring
5 drops red food coloring
In a heavy saucepan, combine butter, sugar, and whipping cream. Cook and stir on low heat until sugar is dissolved. Bring to a boil; cook and stir for 4 minutes.
Remove from heat, stir in white chocolate and marshmallow creme. Remove 1 cup and set aside. Add orange extract and coloring to the remaining mixture. Stir until blended. Pour into an 8 or 9 inch square pan that has been lined with foil and sprayed with nonstick spray. Drop reserved mixture by tablespoons on top and cut through with a knife to swirl.
Let pan cool in refrigerator for several hours until set.
This stuff is absolutely yummy and tastes just like the dreamsicle popsicles I’ve always loved so much. Who says you can’t make fudge in the summer? The Amish certainly don’t.
Happy Friday!





Thanks for visiting my blog! I realize you could be doing more important things with your time. Like watching the news or washing socks. I hope you stay awhile. Much more fun than socks, I promise. 





Well who knew the Amish used fluff?! I guess there are some modern inventions that no one can live without…!
lol My grandparents were Amish so that entire side of my family is Amish. If they have one thing right it's the food!!
I wanted to be Amish too just because life would be simple, peaceful and environmental! But realistically I couldn't live without all this blogging and technology..then I would never find your delicious blog/recipes :)
Why oh why do you not live in Minnesota?!?! If you did I would totally drive to your house and be Amish with you! I, too, have always wanted to give that lifestyle a try (for maybe a week or two, like camp for grown-ups but without Oprah).
Is your Jeep a Commander? What's it in for? Does it happen to have a leaky sunroof that no one seems to be able to fix?! Mine does.
Sometimes I dream of a simpler time too!
Cars… I definitely have a love/hate relationship with them:(
This fudge is like a dreamsicle AND a fudgesicle! Great combo! YUM!
I know I keep repeating myself, but you crack me up:)
Haha! I kind of like the idea of going all Amish for a while. I'll definitely have to try out this fudge. Yum! Great blog :)
Cute post. The fudge looks awesome.
This sounds delish! I'll have to try this sometime. I have a cookies and cream fudge recipe I love but I've been looking for a dreamsicle fudge recipe to try! Thanks for sharing!
I definitely think the Amish know what they're doing when it comes to food. I mean, where would we be without whoopie pies?
Hah! Yo Gabba Gabba… I'm starting to miss that show. Since we've discovered we get Playhouse Disney, the 4y.o insists that is to be on at all times rather than Treehouse :/ I will take DJ Lance over Handy Manny ANY DAY! (Though it took awhile to be able to tolerate it. And what about Biz! That guy is weeeiiird! And the "artist" guy. Ya.)
Yup. I've ignored your recipe, but have commented on the tiny little kids show reference… I'm cool like that. ;)
I hope your Jeep gets well soon. We don't want you completely losing your marbles. This fudge looks amazing! Yay Amish!
I always feel like I need to go somewhere even more when I can't. Kinda like trying not to think about food when you are on a diet. Hope you're not marooned much longer.
Holy cow this looks amazing!!
Ha-ha I love DJ Lance Rock! I'm sure you know all about Asher's obsession with YGG…going on our 6th episode today I think. Arg! On another note, you have my address…and I think snail mail is the popular communication choice of the Amish so I'll keep a look out for some fudge! ;)
I'm not sure how long you could survive the Amish life. How long can one go before serious withdrawal from Teen Mom, Big Brother, and The Real Housewives sets in? And I'm assuming you'll be watching the Bachelorette Men Tell All this week. Have I told you I want to marry Chris L. I love that man! Your fudge looks amazing. Vanilla/orange is a fabulous combo!
That's my favorite fudge!!!! And it has marshmallow cream in it!!! I want some!!!!
And DJ Lance is the best role model. He teaches everyone to be active and have manners. But Brobee is my favorite. He is green and frowns a lot.
WOW!!! That looks so good!!! I have my reservations about DJ Lance too. Especially since my lil girl and him are on a first name basis! Apparently! She calls him "Lance"
[...] not one, but two 13×9 inch pans and that was just too much to experiment with so I found this recipe over at Confessions of a Cookbook Queen on Pinterest that made a much smaller amount and was [...]